In September 2018, Malcom James McCormick, aka, Mac Miller, tragically passed away due to a drug overdose on a laced substance. He passed just one month after the release of his final album “Swimming”, which caught a lot of attention from listeners and countless more after the devastating news. Looking at Malcom’s bodies of work, we can see that he has sonically undergone very unique and unexpected transitions in genre from his beloved classic pop rap, like his 2011 hit single “nikes on my feet” to jazz/ neo-soul and being one of the most prominent representative faces to abstract hip-hop.
In January of 2020, Malcom’s family took to his personal Instagram account to post and inform that an unfinished project of Mac’s will be releasing on January 17th. “Circles”, his Posthumous record, was in the final stages of the recording and mixing process and was set to be the second half to his final album, “swimming”. The theme was that Malcom is “Swimming in Circles”. Multi-instrumentalist and producer, John Bryan, who was working on the production of the album, connected the dots and missing links to present this project as concisely as Mac intended.
Mac’s musical progression since the start of his career has essentially been building up to this record. You can see the beginning of his transition from his 2015 record “GOOD:AM” where mac surprised fans with bringing out his inner singer alongside beautiful neo-soul instrumentals. To “the Devine Feminine” where Mac Completely shifts gear with a funky jazz and a theme of intimacy and love, with the least rap performances of any album he had put out yet.
This transition into a singer/ songwriter is seen very clearly in “Circles”. Pairing that with the executive production by John Bryan, a producer who has worked with artists like Fiona Apple, Aimee Mann, and Elliott smith, it was clear before even listening that this would be the album where Mac deviates from just being a rapper, to becoming a full-on singer/ songwriter.

The record is a beautiful self-reflective journey, where Malcom seems as if he is commentating on his own life posthumously. The first lyric in the album captivates the listener at how self-aware he is; “Well, this is what it looks like, right before you fall”. The album is full of lines like these where it seems like Malcom was anticipating his passing. I would be lying if is said I didn’t shed a tear in my first listen. Being an avid Mac Miller fan since “GOOD:AM” this album was particularly special for me.
Like its first half, “Swimming”, this album also has a very gloomy theme in its production. On the contrary, the melodies and instrumentals seem oddly bright in this album compared to Swimming. Elements like muddy basslines, and muted guitar plucks dull down the bright melodies; giving out this ‘floaty’ feeling similar to his past 2 projects. The album explores themes such as isolation, loneliness and abandonment. You can hear these emotions in Mac’s often raspy vocal performances. Pairing that with spacy instrumentals such as the track “everybody”, where mac performs on a sad classical piano ballad. The Arthur Lee’s “everybody’s gotta live” cover delivers a very touching performance.
On the other hand, some other tracks on the record offer a more upbeat listen; a track like “complicated” where the zingy synth chords and the 4-step jumpy beat sound like a track out of Tyler the Creator’s “Flower Boy”, where it is bright and upbeat with smooth background bass melodies. Also, a track like “Blue World”, with its glitchy chorus on a simple 2-step kick and clap pattern.
Experiencing this album was an absolute pleasure, and it’s very sad to come to terms that this is as far as Mac’s music is going to progress. I think fans could not have expected a better musical sendoff than this album. A truly Heartfelt and sincere performance, Rest in peace Mac.
